Baseball Toaster Cub Town
Help
Clubhouse Turmoil?
2007-06-05 09:10
by Phil Bencomo

Barrett and Zambrano aside, of course (though the two have apparently patched things up). From the Sun-Times:

It's too early and too much of an overstatement to suggest Lou Piniella is losing the clubhouse a mere two months into his first season as Cubs manager.

But his managing style has worn on some veteran players, many of whom spent most of the first two months trying to figure out his lineup patterns and some of whom bristle at his willingness to publicly criticize mistakes -- issues heated to the boiling point by an underachieving start, Monday night's 7-2 victory over the Milwaukee Brewers at Miller Park notwithstanding.

But even privately, players stop well short of suggesting the two-time Manager of the Year is losing the clubhouse, and most characterize it more like ''growing pains'' as a clubhouse full of first-year Cubs gets used to a first-year Cubs manager.

The players can "bristle" all they want, but they remain public figures – entertainers – who are subject to public scrutiny and criticism. If an actor turns in a terrible performance, critics will make it known, and the same holds true for a baseball player.

That being said, I've got to side with the players. Does a director publicly demean his actors? He may do so privately, but if the performance was bad, it will surely be made known by many people – the press, viewers. The last thing an actor or baseball player needs is for his director or manager to add to the public scrutiny. I'm from the school that says coaches should offer constructive criticism, not just fits of fury. After a bad game, does the manager saying to the press, "He was awful out there, and I'm fed up with his mistakes," really do anything but make the player feel worse about himself and his play? The player already knows it, and he doesn't need his manager joining the public critics. If a player is scuffling, the manager should help him out or point him to people who can. That's the manager's job.

These players are people with emotions, just like you and me, who deserve to be treated as such, particularly by the coaching staff. If not even the manager's on your side, what does that do for your morale?

* * * *

The Cubs have looked good the last two days behind a resurgent Alfonso Soriano (10 for his last 15 with three home runs), but at seven games under .500, they're still far from praiseworthy.

* * * *

Jim Hendry is actively trying to trade Jacque Jones, says Fox Sports. With Felix Pie now installed in centerfield after showing better plate discipline at Iowa, either Jones, Cliff Floyd or Matt Murton will have to be moved. Jones, with his -2.7 VORP, is the obvious choice, but with $9 million left on his contract isn't an easy guy to peddle.

* * * *

7:05 game tonight on WGN. Lilly vs. Vargas.

Comments
2007-06-05 10:04:22
1.   kngoworld
What about the tactic used by coaches where they speak negatively to the press about certain players and call them out in order to shake things up and light a fire beneath them. I believe many notable coaches use this tactic among all sports, for example Phil Jackson uses it for struggling and underperforming players and teams. Although, I don't believe a coach has done that with the intentions of "shaking things up" to a team as far down as the Cubs are right now, no offense.
2007-06-05 10:18:08
2.   chicagojosh
I think the difference between Pinella and say, I don't know, Dusty Baker, is that Pinella will say things like "he had a bad game and we need him to start having good games," when talking about players performing poorly. Baker would have said "he's snake bit."

One thing I've noticed this year is that the players are owning up more to their bad performances. The last few years have seen too many "you think you could do better," or "we're doing the best we can," responses.

2007-06-05 10:18:44
3.   Xeifrank
Luckily for the Cubs, they are in a bad division and will probably still win it as soon as Mark Prior and Kerry Woods come back.
vr, Xei
2007-06-05 10:56:10
4.   Phil Bencomo
2 Right. So if the players already know they're performing badly and have owned up to it, do they really need Piniella on their backs, too? Why doesn't Piniella try to help the players, coach them, instead of telling them what they already know. I think that's why the players are getting so "bristled."
2007-06-05 11:59:34
5.   jrshock8
I don't know Phil, I think that maybe what the Cubs needed and have needed is to be called on the carpet for their bad play. For too long they have been allowed to be the Lovable Losers and get away with poor play and execution. The fans are tired of it and I think Pinella is just expressing the same view. Does he go too far sometimes, sure, but I would rather him call them out and make them accountable then baby them. And just maybe his calling them out has led to them taking ownership of their actions. It just seems to me if the player is making the same boneheaded plays over and over, he should be called out if he has not figured it out. I think too many of the players today think they deserve more than they have earned. It is like they just say "Oh well, you just don't understand because you don't play this game and it is tough." Of course they make millions to make mistakes on the field. Ownership of messing up is more than just saying you did something wrong, it is also going out and working on it to get better at it and it seems in the past that has been lacking. Just my two cents. Sorry for the long post, I just think it is time that the Cub players felt a sense of urgency for their job.
2007-06-05 12:25:28
6.   Phil Bencomo
5 But how about some accountability for Lou? Instead of yelling at the players to stop making mistakes, maybe he needs to take a step back and say, "What can I do to help the situation? Am I at fault?" I've heard the players say they're to blame, but when will Piniella (or Hendry, for that matter) stand up himself?

I'd love to just hear Piniella say, "Make a mistake once, shame on you. Make the same mistake twice, shame on me."

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.